Materi
Soal seperti How does paragraph 3 relate to paragraph 2? menanyakan tugas sebuah paragraf. Purdue OWL menjabarkan susunan argumen model Toulmin: claim, pendapat utama penulis; data, bukti yang menopang klaim; counterclaim, pandangan yang menolak klaim; dan rebuttal, bukti penulis yang menjawab pandangan itu. Halaman On Paragraphs di situs yang sama memberi aturan dasarnya: satu gagasan untuk satu paragraf. Karena itu, di teks argumentatif pendek satu paragraf memikul satu tugas.
Tugas itu terbaca dari kalimat pertama paragraf. Halaman Transitions di Purdue OWL menjelaskan bahwa transisi yang baik mengambil frasa kunci paragraf sebelumnya dan menyatakan hubungannya. Penanda yang sering muncul: For example atau One study menandai bukti; Critics argue atau Some people believe menandai pandangan lawan; This concern atau This view yang disusul but menandai bantahan; In short atau Therefore menandai simpulan.
Teks
Paragraph 1. Charging drivers a fee to enter a city centre at busy hours is one of the most effective ways to reduce traffic. When driving into the centre costs money, some trips move to buses, to bicycles, or to quieter times of day.
Paragraph 2. Cities that have tried such a charge report clear results. In one large city, traffic inside the charged zone fell by about a fifth in the first year, and buses that had been stuck in queues began to run on time.
Paragraph 3. Critics argue that the fee is unfair to people on low incomes, who may have no choice but to drive to work.
Paragraph 4. This concern is serious, but it can be answered. In many cities most low-income workers already travel to the centre by bus, and the money collected from the charge can pay for more frequent buses. In that case, the people the critics worry about may gain the most.